Booked and Busy: New Bookstore Opens in Bronxville

Annika Beenhakker ‘26

Periwinkle Books in Bronxville. Photo courtesy of Annika Beenhakker.

Having replaced the decades-old independent bookstore, Womrath Bookshop — which had to close due to unaffordable rent increases — a brand new independent bookshop stands defiantly in Bronxville, New York, in the face of an ever-increasing corporatization of book sales. Still smelling of fresh paint that matches the flower’s color perfectly, Periwinkle Books is a woman-owned bookstore with books both old and new. Now, the challenge is to maintain the independent bookstore in a society where they are quickly disappearing. 

The owner of Periwinkle, Sarah Underhill, and the manager, Allison Devlin, have known each other since they were seven years old and grew up together in Bronxville. Devlin explains that the COVID-19 pandemic created the opportunity for independent bookstores to “rally” and provide for their communities in a time of immense need. Devlin and Underhill were quick to harness the occasion. “Our parents were both in publishing; we’ve always sort of talked about this,” Devlin explains. “The stars aligned when the bookstore became available, and Sarah had the wherewithal to take over the lease and do the whole gut reno. We pinch ourselves sometimes because it is just so exactly what we wanted.” Like their parents, both Underhill and Devlin have experience working in publishing, and have made it their mission to produce a vibrant bookstore where individuals can indulge in a welcoming community surrounding books and reading. 

Previously, Womrath Books stood in the very building that Periwinkle now calls its own. Womrath Books had been open for nearly ninety years before closing, and boasted a series of storefronts around the New York Metropolitan area. The store in Bronxville was the last one standing before the company permanently closed in 2025. Only one year later, Periwinkle Books swooped in to replace Womrath and opened in August with raised ceilings, enlarged windows, and dazzling natural sunlight. “Sarah’s design has made this store extremely appealing … I think as a space it’s magical,” Devlin clarifies. “The selection of books that we’ve curated, and the selection of sidelines that we’ve curated also brings a sense of variety that I don’t think was necessarily at the old bookstore. I think more than anything it’s Sarah and I’s absolute commitment to this community to make sure that this bookstore is a destination that people will come to.” Olivia O’Keefe, who is the Communications Manager at Periwinkle, explains that, “When Womrath was here, I loved the idea of having a bookstore in town, but I never really felt welcome, and I’m sad to say that. We don’t frown at you.” 

Though Sarah Lawrence College advertises an online bookstore where students may buy overpriced books and tacky merchandise, there is nowhere to physically purchase books for class or for pleasure on campus. Sometimes, students are caught in the near-heartstopping realization that a book that is required for class is sold out on the conglomerate monster that is Amazon, only available for the low price of $300 for a first-edition paperback, or will take three weeks to arrive in New York via InterLibrary Loan. “I depend on InterLibrary loans to get my class materials,” Scarlett Davis, ‘27, explains. “That can take weeks to process even though we have a really resourceful library staff.” “It really stinks,” Lucy Weinstein, ‘27, agrees. Worse still, sometimes students realize they forgot to purchase one book for their Literature class, have one week to read the entire novel, and realize they have nowhere to quickly run and buy it at the last minute. “I think it’s a real shame that students don’t have a place to go nearby to get their resources for classes,” Davis continues, “I love that there’s a place within walking distance that I can access if I need it now.” 

Periwinkle Books offers both in-store and online shopping, and is open six days a week from 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Tuesdays through Saturdays, and from noon to 5 p.m. on Sundays. Next time you find yourself in a position necessitating the purchase of a last-minute novel for your Literature class, the bookstore is only a short walk or campus safety van ride away from campus. Periwinkle Books will support you in your studies, and, “More than anything,” Devlin continues, “We wanted to bring a bookstore back to Bronxville that made people excited to be in a bookstore. We want to work with the local school; we want to work with Sarah Lawrence; we want to work with Iona. I mean, we’re a bookstore. That’s exactly what we should be doing.”

Annika Beenhakker

Annika is a senior studying Art History and Nonfiction Writing. Things she loves: Bob Dylan, political caricature, trivia, and romcoms. Things she hates: stubbing her toe and disease.

Next
Next

The A.I. Images Infestation at Sarah Lawrence College