The A.I. Images Infestation at Sarah Lawrence College

Adalyn Harris ‘30

Illustration by Maggie Holsapple ‘29

Everyone has seen them. Whether grabbing a meal at Barb, visiting the Health and Wellness Center, or looking at one of the many TVs around campus, the students of Sarah Lawrence have been subjected to an A.I. model's sad attempt at “artwork.” While disheartening to see off campus, many have been alarmed by A.I.’s increasing presence at a college that promotes creativity and community before all else. It begs the question: if valuing A.I. images above human artwork is acceptable here, what does that bode for the rest of the world? I asked students, especially those taking a Visual Arts Third, about their perspective on the campus's recent infestation. Should Sarah Lawrence come to accept the pests, or is it time for its students to bring out the Raid?

Human versus Machine

Alongside the environmental ramifications, legal complications of using people's likeness without their consent, and the risks it poses to mental health and cognition, generative A.I. usage in visual arts introduces a parasitic new form of competition between human artists and the machines that mimic them. Professionals and students alike fear for their jobs in creative spaces. They know that what was an already vulnerable career is in increasing jeopardy as business executives opt for the “cheap and easy alternative” rather than hiring human talent. Rose Goldberg, a first-year Visual Arts student, argues against this replacement of humanity. She states that, “There is nothing an A.I. bot can create that is more valuable than what a human could ever create… Art is about the human experience, the emotion and effort behind it. Using A.I. takes all of that away.” She and many other Visual Arts students in her situation see A.I. as an unnecessary obstacle in a discipline so dependent on the human experience. How can a machine possibly be able to create “art” when it can’t comprehend what art means? The issues Goldberg and artists like her raise are intensified by the swarm of A.I. images on campus. On the outbreak, she finds that it “brings up the fact that A.I.’s being used so often now and is infiltrating so many things.” Even at a progressive liberal arts college with a lively visual arts community, one still cannot escape the plight of A.I. images. New students must wonder: was this always the case? At what point in the takeover did the Class of 2030 enter?

Changes On Campus

“I’ve noticed them right away,” said Ramona Webb, ‘29, when asked if she had seen the new A.I. images circulating on campus. As a Sophomore Visual Arts student, Ramona has witnessed the evolution of A.I. images on campus over the past year and found that they did not used to be so prevalent. The discussion focused primarily on the images of food recently plaguing the Barb Dining Hall and what they mean for her in regard to student life. “This school has so much creativity and originality in it,” Webb explains. “So many people have this individuality and personal experience that it’s disheartening to see A.I. images.” 

The outwardly cheerful images seem not to boost student morale, but to tread upon it. They bring up the scary but very real possibility that the degree a classmate is striving for, the projects a roommate is labouring over, or the career a senior has been dreaming of may soon not exist at all; all in the attempt to advertise. It is unsurprising that Webb is witnessing a divide between the A.I. images and Sarah Lawrence students' values. 

“Shocking” Advertisements

Webb is not alone in feeling a disconnect between the campus’s creative ethos and the images in question. First-Year Computer Science and Film student, Georgialynn Blue, ‘30, contends that “It’s shocking. As a progressive campus, using A.I. when they could easily let their students create artwork is putting themselves on the wrong foot.” Blue is currently researching generative A.I. regulation and its impact on the environment and society, and she has used that word countless times to describe how the student body feels towards A.I. images: Shocking. 

It goes without saying that Sarah Lawrence students have taken notice of A.I. advertisements. It’s unfortunate, but they seem to have become unavoidable in the current world. However, that does not necessarily make one inclined to buy what the ads are selling. When asking Blue about them, she admits that the A.I. images on campus “make me not really want to look into whatever they are advertising.” She also reasons that “If it’s A.I. generated, I’m not going to trust it.” There’s the irony. Not only are the images counterintuitive to Sarah Lawrence’s ideals, but they are ineffective. So, what can be done? There must be another way of going about these advertisements that benefits the organizations, does not force more work on staff members who already do so much, and is less “shocking” to students. 

The Best of Both Worlds

The solution seems apparent at a liberal arts college: enlist the talents of Sarah Lawrence students to create advertisements rather than A.I. Both of the Visual Arts students interviewed claimed they would be more than willing to make something in replacement of the A.I. images around campus and know plenty of others who would do the same. When considering possible options for the A.I. images removal and advocacy on behalf of Visual Arts students, Blue mentioned alternatives such as work-study opportunities or art contests. Both of which could boost student engagement as well as foster students' passion for the arts. 

A.I. images are not and do not have to be the “future” of the arts. As a progressive liberal arts college, Sarah Lawrence has the opportunity to promote future generations of leaders, writers, inventors and artists. However, that starts with giving students the opportunities to thrive rather than outsourcing to A.I. It’s time these pests are exterminated for good.

Adalyn Harris

Adalyn Harris is a Freelance Writer for The Phoenix. She is in the Class of 2030 and is focusing on Pre-Law related studies. Adalyn enjoys literature, the performing arts, and music above all else. You can find her on instagram @adddy_lovely or in a practice room at Marshall Field.

Previous
Previous

Booked and Busy: New Bookstore Opens in Bronxville

Next
Next

Power Outage, Power Outage